My All-Time Player Rankings

Top 200 Position Players (As of March 2022)

RANK	PLAYER	COMPOSITE SCORE
1	Babe Ruth	100.0
2	Barry Bonds	93.3
3	Ty Cobb	88.0
4	Willie Mays	85.9
5	Ted Williams	83.7
6	Rogers Hornsby	81.4
7	Honus Wagner	81.2
8	Hank Aaron	80.1
9	Tris Speaker	80.0
10	Stan Musial	78.5
11	Lou Gehrig	77.0
12	Eddie Collins	74.3
13	Mickey Mantle	72.3
14	Mel Ott	71.7
15	Alex Rodriguez	70.7
16	Jimmie Foxx	70.2
17	Mike Schmidt	67.8
18	Frank Robinson	67.4
19	Nap Lajoie	66.5
20	Rickey Henderson	66.3
21	Eddie Mathews	63.3
22	Joe Morgan	63.3
23	Carl Yastrzemski	61.9
24	Cap Anson	61.6
25	Joe DiMaggio	61.4
26	Roger Connor	60.7
27	Oscar Charleston	60.1
28	Dan Brouthers	59.8
29	Al Kaline	59.8
30	Wade Boggs	59.7
31	Albert Pujols*	59.4
32	Chipper Jones	59.3
33	Cal Ripken	59.1
34	Jeff Bagwell	58.1
35	Mike Trout*	58.0
36	George Brett	57.8
37	Charlie Gehringer	57.4
38	George Davis	57.3
39	Ed Delahanty	57.0
40	Adrian Beltre	56.0
41	Billy Hamilton	56.0
42	Paul Waner	55.8
43	Ken Griffey Jr.	55.7
44	Roberto Clemente	55.6
45	Frank Thomas	55.6
46	Johnny Mize	55.3
47	Harry Heilmann	55.1
48	Pete Rose	54.8
49	Arky Vaughan	54.7
50	Josh Gibson	54.6
51	Fred Clarke	54.2
52	Al Simmons	54.1
53	Larry Walker	54.0
54	Bill Dahlen	53.9
55	Jim Thome	53.7
56	Frankie Frisch	53.7
57	Hank Greenberg	53.6
58	Manny Ramirez	53.4
59	Luke Appling	53.3
60	Sam Crawford	53.3
61	Cristóbal Torriente	53.3
62	Mark McGwire	53.2
63	Johnny Bench	53.1
64	Miguel Cabrera	53.1
65	Reggie Jackson	53.1
66	Jesse Burkett	53.1
67	Joe Jackson	52.7
68	Brooks Robinson	52.7
69	Rod Carew	52.6
70	Rafael Palmeiro	52.4
71	Derek Jeter	52.3
72	Edgar Martinez	52.2
73	Eddie Murray	52.2
74	Ron Santo	51.9
75	Joe Cronin	51.9
76	Willie McCovey	51.9
77	Scott Rolen	51.6
78	Goose Goslin	51.5
79	Harmon Killebrew	51.4
80	Duke Snider	51.4
81	Willie Wells	51.3
82	Bobby Grich	50.9
83	Mike Piazza	50.6
84	Jim Edmonds	50.6
85	Dick Allen	50.3
86	Paul Molitor	50.3
87	Reggie Smith	50.2
88	Carlos Beltran	50.1
89	Dwight Evans	50.1
90	Jackie Robinson	50.1
91	Willie Stargell	50.0
92	Carlton Fisk	50.0
93	Gary Sheffield	50.0
94	Larry Doby	49.9
95	Zack Wheat	49.9
96	Barry Larkin	49.9
97	Lou Boudreau	49.9
98	Lou Whitaker	49.9
99	Sherry Magee	49.9
100	Joey Votto	49.8
101	Tony Gwynn	49.8
102	Ivan Rodriguez	49.7
103	Tim Raines	49.7
104	Gary Carter	49.7
105	Turkey Stearnes	49.6
106	Andruw Jones	49.4
107	Bob Johnson	49.3
108	Yogi Berra	49.3
109	Bill Terry	49.0
110	Craig Biggio	48.9
111	Frank Baker	48.7
112	Jake Beckley	48.7
113	Joe Gordon	48.6
114	Robin Yount	48.6
115	Roberto Alomar	48.5
116	Ernie Banks	48.4
117	Billy Williams	48.3
118	Joe Torre	48.3
119	Bobby Abreu	48.2
120	Lance Berkman	48.1
121	Elmer Flick	48.1
122	Todd Helton	48.0
122	Joe Kelley	48.0
124	Chase Utley	48.0
125	Bill Dickey	47.9
126	Graig Nettles	47.9
127	Sammy Sosa	47.8
128	Kenny Lofton	47.6
129	Bid McPhee	47.6
130	Alan Trammell	47.5
131	John McGraw	47.5
132	Fred McGriff	47.4
133	Dave Winfield	47.4
134	Darrell Evans	47.3
135	Keith Hernandez	47.2
136	John Olerud	47.2
137	Joe Medwick	47.2
138	Pee Wee Reese	47.0
139	Max Carey	47.0
140	Willie Keeler	46.9
141	Vladimir Guerrero	46.9
142	Ryne Sandberg	46.9
143	Brian Giles	46.9
144	Mickey Cochrane	46.9
145	Robinson Cano*	46.6
146	Ralph Kiner	46.6
147	Ozzie Smith	46.6
148	Gabby Hartnett	46.5
149	Bobby Bonds	46.5
150	Minnie Minoso	46.5
151	Kiki Cuyler	46.5
152	Stan Hack	46.5
153	Tony Perez	46.4
154	Norm Cash	46.4
155	Harry Stovey	46.4
156	Jimmy Sheckard	46.4
157	Bobby Wallace	46.3
158	Willie Randolph	46.3
159	Andre Dawson	46.3
160	Richie Ashburn	46.2
161	Buddy Bell	46.2
162	Jud Wilson	46.2
163	George Sisler	46.1
164	Buster Posey	46.1
165	Earl Averill	46.1
166	Charlie Keller	46.0
167	Jeff Kent	46.0
168	John Henry Lloyd	45.9
169	Bobby Doerr	45.8
170	David Ortiz	45.7
171	Jack Glasscock	45.6
172	Luis Gonzalez	45.5
173	Will Clark	45.3
174	Jason Giambi	45.3
175	Enos Slaughter	45.3
176	Robin Ventura	45.3
177	Billy Herman	45.2
178	Ron Cey	45.1
179	Tony Lazzeri	45.0
180	Pete Hill	44.9
181	David Wright	44.8
182	Ken Boyer	44.8
183	Sal Bando	44.7
184	Hugh Duffy	44.7
185	Roy Campanella	44.7
186	Bob Elliott	44.7
187	Matt Holliday	44.6
188	Jack Clark	44.5
189	Jim Rice	44.5
190	Pete Browning	44.5
191	Jimmy Wynn	44.4
192	Edd Roush	44.4
193	Harry Hooper	44.3
194	Ichiro Suzuki	44.2
195	Sam Rice	44.1
196	Frank Chance	44.1
197	Joe Mauer	44.0
197	Jimmy Collins	44.0
199	Sam Thompson	44.0
200	Hack Wilson	44.0

Top 50 Pitchers (As of March 2022)

1	Roger Clemens	78.38
2	Cy Young	69.69
3	Walter Johnson	67.43
4	Randy Johnson	67.37
5	Greg Maddux	65.54
6	Pedro Martinez	61.37
7	Nolan Ryan	57.22
8	Christy Mathewson	56.65
9	Bert Blyleven	56.57
10	Lefty Grove	56.17
11	Pete Alexander	54.89
12	Clayton Kershaw*	54.57
13	Gaylord Perry	52.85
14	Curt Schilling	52.59
15	John Smoltz	50.74
16	Mike Mussina	50.54
17	Tom Seaver	49.79
18	Steve Carlton	49.68
19	Kevin Brown	49.54
20	Bob Gibson	49.24
21	Mariano Rivera	48.56
22	Rube Waddell	48.19
23	Max Scherzer*	47.89
24	Justin Verlander*	46.01
25	Jacob deGrom*	45.87
26	Roy Halladay	45.13
27	Chris Sale*	44.94
28	Kid Nichols	43.99
29	Dazzy Vance	43.61
30	Sandy Koufax	43.39
31	Fergie Jenkins	42.29
32	Andy Pettitte	41.90
33	Don Sutton	41.83
34	Tommy John	41.14
35	Hal Newhouser	40.65
36	Satchel Paige	40.58
37	Rick Reuschel	40.16
38	Zack Greinke*	40.15
39	Roy Oswalt	40.03
40	Eddie Plank	39.13
41	Bret Saberhagen	38.50
42	Tim Keefe	38.23
42	John Clarkson	38.23
44	Paul Derringer	37.85
45	Corey Kluber*	37.81
46	CC Sabathia	37.75
47	Dennis Eckersley	37.61
48	Robin Roberts	37.54
49	Dwight Gooden	37.32
50	Jim Bunning	37.04