I have recently encountered difficulty getting images related to this checklist to consistently appear as intended. Use the textual checklist below while I work out how to repair the more visually appealing layout previously used.
| # | Name | Status | Team | Card Note |
| 1 | David Justice | PSA 9 | Atlanta Braves | |
| 2 | Lou Whitaker | PSA 9 | Detroit Tigers | |
| 3 | Bryan Harvey | PSA 9 | Florida Marlins | |
| 4 | Carlos Garcia | PSA 9 | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 5 | Sid Fernandez | PSA 9 | New York Mets | |
| 6 | Brett Butler | PSA 9 | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 7 | Scott Cooper | PSA 7 | Boston Red Sox | |
| 8 | BJ Surhoff | PSA 9 | Milwaukee Brewers | |
| 9 | Steve Finley | PSA 8 | Houston Astros | |
| 10 | Curt Schilling | PSA 9 | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 11 | Jeff Bagwell | PSA 8 | Houston Astros | |
| 12 | Alex Cole | PSA 9 | Colorado Rockies | |
| 13 | John Olerud | PSA 8 | Toronto Blue Jays | |
| 14 | John Smiley | PSA 8 | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 15 | Bip Roberts | PSA 9 | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 16 | Albert Belle | PSA 8 | Cleveland Indians | |
| 17 | Duane Ward | PSA 9 | Toronto Blue Jays | |
| 18 | Alan Trammell | PSA 8 | Detroit Tigers | |
| 19 | Andy Benes | PSA 8 | San Diego Padres | |
| 20 | Reggie Sanders | PSA 8 | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 21 | Todd Zeile | PSA 9 | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 22 | Rick Aguilera | PSA 8 | Minnesota Twins | |
| 23 | Dave Hollins | PSA 9 | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 24 | Jose Rijo | PSA 9 | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 25 | Matt Williams | PSA 8 | San Francisco Giants | |
| 26 | Sandy Alomar, Jr. | PSA 8 | Cleveland Indians | |
| 27 | Alex Fernandez | PSA 9 | Chicago White Sox | |
| 28 | Ozzie Smith | PSA 8 | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 29 | Ramon Martinez | PSA 8 | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 30 | Bernie Williams | PSA 8 | New York Yankees | |
| 31 | Gary Sheffield | PSA 8 | San Diego Padres | |
| 32 | Eric Karros | PSA 9 | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 33 | Frank Viola | PSA 9 | Boston Red Sox | |
| 34 | Kevin Young | PSA 8 | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 35 | Ken Hill | PSA 8 | Montreal Expos | |
| 36 | Tony Fernandez | PSA 8 | New York Mets | |
| 37 | Tim Wakefield | PSA 9 | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 38 | John Kruk | PSA 8 | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 39 | Chris Sabo | PSA 8 | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 40 | Marquis Grissom | PSA 9 | Montreal Expos | |
| 41 | Glenn Davis | PSA 8 | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 42 | Jeff Montgomery | PSA 8 | Kansas City Royals | |
| 43 | Kenny Lofton | PSA 9 | Cleveland Indians | |
| 44 | John Burkett | PSA 8 | San Francisco Giants | |
| 45 | Darryl Hamilton | PSA 8 | Milwaukee Brewers | |
| 46 | Jim Abbott | PSA 9 | New York Yankees | |
| 47 | Ivan Rodriguez | SGC 8 | Texas Rangers | |
| 48 | Eric Young | PSA 9 | Colorado Rockies | |
| 49 | Mitch Williams | PSA 9 | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 50 | Harold Reynolds | PSA 8 | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 51 | Brian Harper | PSA 8 | Minnesota Twins | |
| 52 | Rafael Palmeiro | PSA 9 | Texas Rangers | |
| 53 | Bret Saberhagen | PSA 9 | New York Mets | |
| 54 | Jeff Conine | PSA 8 | Florida Marlins | |
| 55 | Ivan Calderon | PSA 8 | Boston Red Sox | |
| 56 | Juan Guzman | PSA 8 | Toronto Blue Jays | |
| 57 | Carlos Baerga | PSA 9 | Cleveland Indians | |
| 58 | Charles Nagy | PSA 9 | Cleveland Indians | |
| 59 | Wally Joyner | PSA 8 | Kansas City Royals | |
| 60 | Charlie Hayes | PSA 8 | Colorado Rockies | |
| 61 | Shane Mack | PSA 8 | Minnesota Twins | |
| 62 | Pete Harnisch | PSA 9 | Houston Astros | |
| 63 | George Brett | PSA 8 | Kansas City Royals | |
| 64 | Lance Johnson | PSA 9 | Chicago White Sox | |
| 65 | Ben McDonald | PSA 8.5 | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 66 | Bobby Bonilla | PSA 8 | New York Mets | |
| 67 | Terry Steinbach | PSA 8 | Oakland Athletics | |
| 68 | Ron Gant | PSA 8 | Atlanta Braves | |
| 69 | Doug Jones | PSA 8 | Houston Astros | |
| 70 | Paul Molitor | PSA 7 | Toronto Blue Jays | |
| 71 | Brady Anderson | PSA 9 | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 72 | Chuck Finley | PSA 8 | California Angels | |
| 73 | Mark Grace | PSA 9 | Chicago Cubs | |
| 74 | Mike Devereaux | PSA 9 | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 75 | Tony Phillips | PSA 9 | Detroit Tigers | |
| 76 | Chuck Knoblauch | PSA 8 | Minnesota Twins | |
| 77 | Tony Gwynn | PSA 8 | San Diego Padres | |
| 78 | Kevin Appier | PSA 9 | Kansas City Royals | |
| 79 | Sammy Sosa | PSA 8 | Chicago White Sox | |
| 80 | Mickey Tettleton | PSA 8 | Detroit Tigers | |
| 81 | Felix Jose | PSA 8 | Kansas City Royals | |
| 82 | Mark Langston | PSA 9 | California Angels | |
| 83 | Gregg Jefferies | PSA 8.5 | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 84 | Andre Dawson | PSA 9 | Boston Red Sox | All-Star |
| 85 | Greg Maddux | PSA 8 | Atlanta Braves | All-Star |
| 86 | Rickey Henderson | PSA 9 | Oakland Athletics | All-Star |
| 87 | Tom Glavine | PSA 8 | Atlanta Braves | All-Star |
| 88 | Roberto Alomar | PSA 9 | Toronto Blue Jays | All-Star |
| 89 | Darryl Strawberry | PSA 8 | Los Angeles Dodgers | All-Star |
| 90 | Wade Boggs | PSA 9 | New York Yankees | All-Star |
| 91 | Bo Jackson | PSA 9 | Chicago White Sox | All-Star |
| 92 | Mark McGwire | PSA 9 | Oakland Athletics | All-Star |
| 93 | Robin Ventura | PSA 8 | Chicago White Sox | All-Star |
| 94 | Joe Carter | PSA 9 | Toronto Blue Jays | All-Star |
| 95 | Lee Smith | PSA 8 | St. Louis Cardinals | All-Star |
| 96 | Cal Ripken, Jr. | PSA 9oc | Baltimore Orioles | All-Star |
| 97 | Larry Walker | PSA 9 | Montreal Expos | All-Star |
| 98 | Don Mattingly | SGC 7 | New York Yankees | All-Star |
| 99 | Jose Canseco | PSA 8 | Texas Rangers | All-Star |
| 100 | Dennis Eckersley | PSA 8 | Oakland Athletics | All-Star |
| 101 | Terry Pendleton | PSA 8 | Atlanta Braves | All-Star |
| 102 | Frank Thomas | PSA 8 | Chicago White Sox | All-Star |
| 103 | Barry Bonds | PSA 9 | San Francisco Giants | All-Star |
| 104 | Roger Clemens | PSA 8 | Boston Red Sox | All-Star |
| 105 | Ryne Sandberg | PSA 9 | Chicago Cubs | All-Star |
| 106 | Fred McGriff | PSA 9 | San Diego Padres | All-Star |
| 107 | Nolan Ryan | PSA 7 | Texas Rangers | All-Star |
| 108 | Will Clark | PSA 9 | San Francisco Giants | All-Star |
| 109 | Pat Listach | PSA 9 | Milwaukee Brewers | All-Star |
| 110 | Ken Griffey, Jr. | PSA 8 | Seattle Mariners | All-Star |
| 111 | Cecil Fielder | PSA 9 | Detroit Tigers | All-Star |
| 112 | Kirby Puckett | PSA 8 | Minnesota Twins | All-Star |
| 113 | Doc Gooden | PSA 9 | New York Mets | All-Star |
| 114 | Barry Larkin | PSA 7 | Cincinnati Reds | All-Star |
| 115 | David Cone | PSA 8 | Kansas City Royals | All-Star |
| 116 | Juan Gonzalez | PSA 9 | Texas Rangers | All-Star |
| 117 | Kent Hrbek | PSA 8 | Minnesota Twins | |
| 118 | Tim Wallach | PSA 8 | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 119 | Craig Biggio | PSA 8 | Houston Astros | |
| 120 | Bobby Kelly | PSA 9 | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 121 | Gregg Olson | PSA 8 | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 122 | Eddie Murray | PSA 9 | New York Mets | |
| 123 | Wil Cordero | BGS 8.5 | Montreal Expos | |
| 124 | Jay Buhner | PSA 8 | Seattle Mariners | |
| 125 | Carlton Fisk | PSA 8 | Chicago White Sox | |
| 126 | Eric Davis | PSA 9 | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 127 | Doug Drabek | PSA 8 | Houston Astros | |
| 128 | Ozzie Guillen | PSA 8 | Chicago White Sox | |
| 129 | John Wetteland | PSA 9 | Montreal Expos | |
| 130 | Andres Galarraga | PSA 9 | Colorado Rockies | |
| 131 | Ken Caminiti | PSA 8 | Houston Astros | |
| 132 | Tom Candiotti | PSA 9 | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 133 | Pat Borders | PSA 8 | Toronto Blue Jays | |
| 134 | Kevin Brown | PSA 9 | Texas Rangers | |
| 135 | Travis Fryman | PSA 9 | Detroit Tigers | |
| 136 | Kevin Mitchell | PSA 8 | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 137 | Greg Swindell | PSA 9 | Houston Astros | |
| 138 | Benny Santiago | PSA 9 | Florida Marlins | |
| 139 | Reggie Jefferson | PSA 9 | Cleveland Indians | |
| 140 | Chris Bosio | PSA 9 | Seattle Mariners | |
| 141 | Deion Sanders | PSA 8 | Atlanta Braves | |
| 142 | Scott Erickson | PSA 9 | Minnesota Twins | |
| 143 | Howard Johnson | PSA 8 | New York Mets | |
| 144 | Orestes Destrade | PSA 8 | Florida Marlins | |
| 145 | Jose Guzman | PSA 9 | Chicago Cubs | |
| 146 | Chad Curtis | PSA 8 | California Angels | |
| 147 | Cal Eldred | PSA 9 | Milwaukee Brewers | |
| 148 | Willie Greene | PSA 8 | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 149 | Tommy Greene | PSA 9 | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 150 | Erik Hanson | PSA 9 | Seattle Mariners | |
| 151 | Bob Welch | PSA 9 | Oakland Athletics | |
| 152 | John Jaha | PSA 8 | Milwaukee Brewers | |
| 153 | Harold Baines | PSA 8 | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 154 | Randy Johnson | PSA 9 | Seattle Mariners | |
| 155 | Al Martin | PSA 8 | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 156 | JT Snow | PSA 8 | California Angels | Rookie Card |
| 157 | Mike Mussina | PSA 7 | Baltimore Orioles | |
| 158 | Ruben Sierra | PSA 8 | Oakland Athletics | |
| 159 | Dean Palmer | PSA 8 | Texas Rangers | |
| 160 | Steve Avery | PSA 8 | Atlanta Braves | |
| 161 | Julio Franco | PSA 8 | Texas Rangers | |
| 162 | Dave Winfield | PSA 8 | Minnesota Twins | |
| 163 | Tim Salmon | PSA 9 | California Angels | |
| 164 | Tom Henke | PSA 9 | Texas Rangers | |
| 165 | Mo Vaughn | PSA 8.5 | Boston Red Sox | |
| 166 | John Smoltz | PSA 7 | Atlanta Braves | |
| 167 | Danny Tartabull | PSA 8 | New York Yankees | |
| 168 | Delino DeShields | PSA 8 | Montreal Expos | |
| 169 | Charlie Hough | PSA 9 | Florida Marlins | |
| 170 | Paul O’Neill | PSA 8 | New York Yankees | |
| 171 | Darren Daulton | PSA 9 | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 172 | Jack McDowell | PSA 8 | Chicago White Sox | |
| 173 | Junior Felix | PSA 8 | Florida Marlins | |
| 174 | Jimmy Key | PSA 9 | New York Yankees | |
| 175 | George Bell | PSA 8 | Chicago White Sox | |
| 176 | Mike Stanton | PSA 8 | Atlanta Braves | |
| 177 | Len Dykstra | PSA 8 | Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 178 | Norm Charlton | PSA 8 | Seattle Mariners | |
| 179 | Eric Anthony | PSA 8 | Houston Astros | |
| 180 | Rob Dibble | PSA 8 | Cincinnati Reds | |
| 181 | Otis Nixon | PSA 8 | Atlanta Braves | |
| 182 | Randy Myers | PSA 9 | Chicago Cubs | |
| 183 | Tim Raines | PSA 8 | Chicago White Sox | |
| 184 | Orel Hershiser | PSA 9 | Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 185 | Andy Van Slyke | PSA 8 | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 186 | Mike Lansing | PSA 8 | Montreal Expos | Rookie Card |
| 187 | Ray Lankford | PSA 8 | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 188 | Mike Morgan | PSA 8 | Chicago Cubs | |
| 189 | Moises Alou | PSA 8.5 | Montreal Expos | |
| 190 | Edgar Martinez | PSA 8 | Seattle Mariners | |
| 191 | John Franco | PSA 8 | New York Mets | |
| 192 | Robin Yount | PSA 8 | Milwaukee Brewers | |
| 193 | Bob Tewksbury | PSA 9 | St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 194 | Jay Bell | PSA 8 | Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 195 | Luis Gonzalez | PSA 8 | Houston Astros | |
| 196 | Dave Fleming | PSA 8 | Seattle Mariners | |
| 197 | Mike Greenwell | PSA 7 | Boston Red Sox | |
| 198 | David Nied | PSA 9 | Colorado Rockies | |
| 199 | Mike Piazza | PSA 9 | Los Angeles Dodgers |